Discussion Guidelines

Each day, class will consist of a discussion of the assigned papers. Each student will be asked to lead at least one discussion during the semester. On the day of your discussion, please submit your materials (slides, notes, etc.) by editing the class page on this wiki. You should plan for your discussion to fill 45 minutes.
There are several goals for the discussion:
  • To lead a conversation about the papers, covering topics much like those that would be covered in a critique. You should not do all the talking, but you need to be willing to step in at any point when no one else is providing new ideas or questions.
  • To get people talking! One great way to do this is to break people into pairs or small groups for a minute or two to think about a question. Pairs and small groups give more students a chance to participate, and they help students get ideas and words flowing.
  • To touch on the high and low level parts of the readings. High level concepts are important, they help us anchor on the topic and give us some motivation for a research topic, but also don't be afraid to really dive into the details of how a study was performed, or whether the right research question was asked.
  • Assume people have read the papers and are ready to talk. Keep any summary short. If you get a sense that students are unclear on some of the concepts, feel free to recap important points and details; but in general, focus on discussion, not summarization.

Before class on the day of your discussion, read through all other students' critiques. (They will be available as comments in Google Plus). You are expected to weave ideas from everyone's critiques into the discussion.

Optional: While not required, if there are any questions that really are open, I encourage you to contact the author(s) of the paper (more than a day in advance). Tell them we are reading their paper for the class and that you wanted their current thinking on ... whatever the open issues are.

After class, please summarize the most salient points from the class discussion and post as a follow-up comment on Google Plus.